The Great Corporate Debate 2010
¡La competencia finalizó este 18 de agosto!
Los equipos finalistas:
D&S vs. Direcon
Ganador: Direcon
Tema:When a state of emergency in an area is declared by the President, the armed forces must be sent into the area immediately to maintain law and order.
D&S Yes
Direcon No
Los ocho equipos que participan en The Great Corporate Debate 2010 participaron en sesiones de entrenamiento y el lunes 12 de Julio comenzaron las rondas preliminares de esta competencia de debates en inglés. Debate Final: Miércoles 18 de Agosto, 19 hrs. en Salón Club de Lectores El Mercurio.
Vea las intervenciones de cada equipo:
D&S introducción
Direcon introducción
Constructive D&S
Constructive Direcon
Rebuttal Direcon
Rebuttal D&S
Conclusion Direcon
Conclusion D&S
Judge´s comments
Los profesionales de Codelco, D&S, Direcon, Hotel Sheraton, Parque Arauco, Ripley, Seguros Interamericana y 3M que participan en esta versión recibieron clases de inglés y de oratoria, capacitación que forma parte de esta competencia.
Los equipos conocen los temas –y que postura dentro de cada tema- deben defender con varios días de antelación, lo que les permite investigar y preparar su argumentación.
Durante 6 jornadas los equipos se enfrentaron en debates que tuvieron como tema central la reconstrucción del país.
La Gran Final se llevó a cabo el 18 de Agosto en El Mercurio. Asistieron altas autoridades y expertos, quienes conformarán el jurado.
Primer Encuentro: Lunes 12 de Julio de 2010
1er Debate: The reconstruction program for those that suffered in February´s earthquake must be based on government loans and credit guarantees and not cash gifts.
Codelco Postura: Yes
Ripley Postura: No
2do Debate: Chilean airports, hospitals, and schools must have substantially higher standards of construction to withstand natural disasters such as earthquakes.
3M Postura: Yes
Seguros Interamericana Postura: No
Segundo Encuentro: Miércoles 14 de Julio de 2010
1er Debate: Legislation needs to be passed immediately allowing the private sector to receive tax incentives for investing in the repair of national heritage sites damaged by the 2010 earthquake.
Direcon Postura: Yes
D&S Postura: No
2do Debate: Legislation needs to be passed requiring insurance companies to settle claims for damage from earthquakes or other natural disasters within a maximum of sixty days
Sheraton Postura: Yes
Parque Arauco Postura: No
Tercer Encuentro: Lunes 19 de julio de 2010
1er Debate: Seismology should be an obligatory subject in Chilean schools.
Seguros Interamericana Postura: Yes
Ripley Postura: No
2do Debate: When natural disasters occur be they earthquakes, tsunamis, or volcanic eruptions, the government should fix a time period not exceeding two years by which time the damage must be repaired.
Codelco Postura: Yes
3M Postura: No
Cuarto Encuentro: Miércoles 21 de julio de 2010
1er Debate: A seismographic network using the best equipment available and connected to international networks must be installed in universities allowing Chilean scientists to become world leaders in earthquake prediction.
Parque Arauco Postura: Yes
Direcon Postura: No
2do Debate: The reconstruction of 2010 earthquake damage should be financed by increasing corporate taxes on a temporary basis.
D&S Postura: Yes
Sheraton Postura: No
Quinto Encuentro, 26 de Julio
Chile needs a second North South high voltage transmission line following a route different from the first to ensure the security of power supplies in the event of major natural disasters.
Ripley Postura: Yes
3M Postura: No
2do Debate:
Chile´s building codes must be improved to levels such that all buildings can remain safely inhabited after an earthquake.
Seguros Interamericana Postura: Yes
Codelco Postura: No
Quinto Encuentro: Miércoles 28 de Julio
1er Debate:
A reliable and easily recognizable early warning system for tsunamis needs to be installed throughout Chile.
Direcon Yes
Sheraton No
2do Debate:
Nuclear power is the only realistic option for Chile´s future energy requirements.
D&S Yes
Parque Arauco No
Semifinal: 4 de Agosto
1er Debate:
The government should not permit buildings to be rebuilt in those reconstruction areas determined to suffer damage from future tsunamis.
3M Yes
D&S No
2do Debate: Telephone systems in Chile must be made earthquake proof.
Interamericana Yes
Direcon No
¡La competencia finalizó este 18 de agosto!
Los equipos finalistas:
D&S vs. Direcon
Ganador: Direcon
Tema:When a state of emergency in an area is declared by the President, the armed forces must be sent into the area immediately to maintain law and order.
D&S Yes
Direcon No
Los ocho equipos que participan en The Great Corporate Debate 2010 participaron en sesiones de entrenamiento y el lunes 12 de Julio comenzaron las rondas preliminares de esta competencia de debates en inglés. Debate Final: Miércoles 18 de Agosto, 19 hrs. en Salón Club de Lectores El Mercurio.
Vea las intervenciones de cada equipo:
D&S introducción
Direcon introducción
Constructive D&S
Constructive Direcon
Rebuttal Direcon
Rebuttal D&S
Conclusion Direcon
Conclusion D&S
Judge´s comments
Los profesionales de Codelco, D&S, Direcon, Hotel Sheraton, Parque Arauco, Ripley, Seguros Interamericana y 3M que participan en esta versión recibieron clases de inglés y de oratoria, capacitación que forma parte de esta competencia.
Los equipos conocen los temas –y que postura dentro de cada tema- deben defender con varios días de antelación, lo que les permite investigar y preparar su argumentación.
Durante 6 jornadas los equipos se enfrentaron en debates que tuvieron como tema central la reconstrucción del país.
La Gran Final se llevó a cabo el 18 de Agosto en El Mercurio. Asistieron altas autoridades y expertos, quienes conformarán el jurado.
Primer Encuentro: Lunes 12 de Julio de 2010
1er Debate: The reconstruction program for those that suffered in February´s earthquake must be based on government loans and credit guarantees and not cash gifts.
Codelco Postura: Yes
Ripley Postura: No
2do Debate: Chilean airports, hospitals, and schools must have substantially higher standards of construction to withstand natural disasters such as earthquakes.
3M Postura: Yes
Seguros Interamericana Postura: No
Segundo Encuentro: Miércoles 14 de Julio de 2010
1er Debate: Legislation needs to be passed immediately allowing the private sector to receive tax incentives for investing in the repair of national heritage sites damaged by the 2010 earthquake.
Direcon Postura: Yes
D&S Postura: No
2do Debate: Legislation needs to be passed requiring insurance companies to settle claims for damage from earthquakes or other natural disasters within a maximum of sixty days
Sheraton Postura: Yes
Parque Arauco Postura: No
Tercer Encuentro: Lunes 19 de julio de 2010
1er Debate: Seismology should be an obligatory subject in Chilean schools.
Seguros Interamericana Postura: Yes
Ripley Postura: No
2do Debate: When natural disasters occur be they earthquakes, tsunamis, or volcanic eruptions, the government should fix a time period not exceeding two years by which time the damage must be repaired.
Codelco Postura: Yes
3M Postura: No
Cuarto Encuentro: Miércoles 21 de julio de 2010
1er Debate: A seismographic network using the best equipment available and connected to international networks must be installed in universities allowing Chilean scientists to become world leaders in earthquake prediction.
Parque Arauco Postura: Yes
Direcon Postura: No
2do Debate: The reconstruction of 2010 earthquake damage should be financed by increasing corporate taxes on a temporary basis.
D&S Postura: Yes
Sheraton Postura: No
Quinto Encuentro, 26 de Julio
Chile needs a second North South high voltage transmission line following a route different from the first to ensure the security of power supplies in the event of major natural disasters.
Ripley Postura: Yes
3M Postura: No
2do Debate:
Chile´s building codes must be improved to levels such that all buildings can remain safely inhabited after an earthquake.
Seguros Interamericana Postura: Yes
Codelco Postura: No
Quinto Encuentro: Miércoles 28 de Julio
1er Debate:
A reliable and easily recognizable early warning system for tsunamis needs to be installed throughout Chile.
Direcon Yes
Sheraton No
2do Debate:
Nuclear power is the only realistic option for Chile´s future energy requirements.
D&S Yes
Parque Arauco No
Semifinal: 4 de Agosto
1er Debate:
The government should not permit buildings to be rebuilt in those reconstruction areas determined to suffer damage from future tsunamis.
3M Yes
D&S No
2do Debate: Telephone systems in Chile must be made earthquake proof.
Interamericana Yes
Direcon No